Showing posts with label Wagner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wagner. Show all posts

Friday, 10 May 2013

It's not just me, then

Nazi-themed Wagner opera pulled after walkouts



Following my recent criticism of the Royal Opera House holocaust themed "Nabucco",  here's one even worse.

I have a great deal of time for Wagner, and it is certainly possible to make a good argument that his anti-Semitic leanings are worthy of being addressed in productions. But "Tannhauser"  has nothing to say that could be appropriate for such explicit reference to the Holocaust. In fact, it's the story of a young man seeking redemption following some ill-advised bonking. This is just the wrong place for such allusions.

I have clearly not seen the production, so my criticism here is based on my knowledge of "Tannhauser" itself and on just how uncomfortable it felt watching a much milder Holocaust allegory in the recent "Nabucco".
I don't know if I am ready for the Holocaust as entertainment. It seems I'm not the only one. Maybe we need to wait another generation for that.

Sunday, 3 June 2012

höchste Lust!

A quick note, and a recommendation. I saw Welsh National Opera's Tristan und Isolde at the Wales Millennium Centre last night. Absolutely awesome. I think there's only one more performance, which I believe is in Birmingham on June 16. If you get a chance, go.



"Tristan" is a work I was very familiar with in my misspent youth, experienced, libretto in hand, mainly listening to Solti's Decca recording on 5 LPs, with Birgit Nilsson.


Oh the magic of those old boxed sets! I've just pulled it out of my record collection for the first time in many years (to take this photo), and I can tell you right now, if I had a working record deck, that would be me for the rest of the day.

As a result, most of my previous experience of Wagner, and Tristan in particular, is in sound only. The "pictures" were all in my head. I have to say, there were a few times in last night's performance, where I closed my eyes and just soaked up the music. This was particularly so in the three overtures, which were rich and moving - and the tone from the orchestra pit gave a dimension to the music missing from my old black vinyl and the Spotify version I've been using to re-familiarise myself with the work. Sometimes the presence of the audience was a bit of an intrusion on a very personal experience. Of course, once the actors were on stage, there was plenty to see, and the modern use of surtitles means that I can now follow the details of the libretto every bit as well in the theatre as I used to when listening at home. Wagner really needs that detail. There are few, if any, show-piece arias and no Italian-style sing-along numbers. This is all about the drama, and it is all done in music at every step of the way. If you don't know what they are singing about at any given point, it's actually extremely difficult to appreciate either the music or the drama.

Now; an essential skill for the opera aficionado is the ability to suspend disbelief. After all, life isn't generally sung! But there's even more suspending to do when the heroic tenor medieval knight turns out to have had far too many super-size meals from McD's. My apologies to any comfortably-built tenors who may read this, but I just can't picture you taking on the warrior hero of Ireland and giving him a drubbing in hand to hand combat! However, close your eyes, and the voice is simply wonderful. Ben Heppner (Tristan) really came into his own in the third act, when his wounded hero gets the chance to sing his love and agony away from the vocal shadow of Isolde.

In many ways, it's all easier when listening to records and matching the real (and amazing) voice to an imagined hero. However, the bottom line is the music, and Wagner totally nails it here. If you are not familiar with Wagner, this is not a great place to start. You really need to have spent some time getting your head round his way of working and expressing emotion and drama. I can see how inaccessible it must sometimes appear - but how it is worth it! Once you've worked your way into the Wagner mindset, it becomes a magical, transporting place. The music sucks you into the drama and the inner emotional lives of the protagonists. In the dénouement of the WNO production, as she sings her epic final piece, Isolde removes her black cloak to reveal a white gown; the dress for her wedding to Tristan. Ultimately, we are left with nothing but the internal emotions of Isolde - everything else has fallen to nothing. In many productions, Isolde finishes by collapsing dead on Tristan's body. The WNO production instead achieves more by gradually dimming all light on the stage to leave finally nothing but Isolde's face illuminated. So absorbing was Anne Petersen's Liebestod that it was a while before I even noticed that everything else had disappeared. In the drama, Isolde is singing her own death - but her song is desperate and blissful. It is entirely appropriate that the audience is effectively drawn into Isolde's personal, isolated inner world, to the exclusion of all else. That is the real end of the drama - and it's utterly wrenching. Of course I cried like a big baby. I knew I would, but it speaks volumes for this performance that it hit me so hard. I even had another blub when Anne Petersen came out for applause at the end.

Draining. Wonderful. If I could go to this again today, I would.

Saturday, 16 July 2011

It's all gone a bit silly

Oh dear. Following my "Wagner" experiences a few weeks ago (for which Stephen Fry and BBC 4 are not without blame), my Spotify playlist has taken an increasingly operatic turn. As well as dipping back in to my old Wagner haunts, I have also been tempted into Italian opera. Now there's a thing. In my full-blown opera-loving teenage years, I tried a bit of Verdi (quite liked Aida and really liked the pyrotechnics of the huge drums in his Requiem), but no more than that. It all seemed a bit too Andrew Lloyd-Webber after Wagner. And, in those days, it even mattered to me that Wagner himself didn't think much of Joe Green.

Anyway - almost accidentally I picked up a Deutsche Gramophon Verdi sampler from a Spotify playlist, and this time, nearly 30 years on, it really hit the spot.

Verdi Highlights

It doesn't have the visceral drama of Wagner - but those tunes are big and meaty and just all-round fabulous! Co-incidentally, I chanced across La Traviata on Sky Arts, and (because the rest of the family were busy with school work) ended up watching the whole thing. (It's La Dame aux Camélias in opera form - who knew?) I'm not sure I'll ever get used to the audience applauding at the end of "numbers". You can see why Wagner looked down his considerable Teutonic nose - but how fabulous was the music?

Have I gone over to the dark side?

A few train journeys and shopping trips with Verdi on my Android - and I was ready for more. Oh yes. Puccini. A bit of Turnadot and Butterfly. I know! Where will it all lead?

Puccini Highlights

With any luck this is another phase and I'll be back to Indie guitar, or maybe Beethoven, before you know it.

Hehehe - loving it really.

Another shopping trip round Tesco today. I managed to give the opera a skip this time - and listened to Pergolesi's Stabat Mater. Mighty fine too. Maybe I should just get on and enjoy it.

I promise my next post will be Opera-free...